Bare trees in fog with a distant white building

Dark Reflections Series Presents: Defoe & Graven

A Classic Compare & Contrast Analysis Of Two Authors' Works

Reflection 12 ~ Daniel Defoe's A Journal of the Plague Year

Dark Reflections
Dark Reflections
The Gothic Mirror
The Gothic Mirror

This material is part of a larger non-profit literary collection: Dark Reflections Series, and features work comparison and contrast between between two authors, Daniel Defoe (A Journal of the Plague Year) and G.E. Graven (Grotesque: A Gothic Epic).

Bare trees in fog with a distant white building

Daniel Defoe’s A Journal of the Plague Year and G. E. Graven’s Grotesque: A Gothic Epic both transform epidemic disease into a Gothic literature of social fear, bodily vulnerability, death, and moral testing. Yet they do so through sharply different imaginative frameworks. Defoe presents plague primarily as a historically grounded catastrophe observed through the anxious, practical consciousness of a Londoner; Graven reimagines the Black Death as the opening movement of a supernatural apocalypse, a demonic weapon that converts historical pandemic into mythic warfare.

The central contrast may be stated this way:

Defoe asks how human beings behave when an epidemic overwhelms ordinary social life; Graven asks what the epidemic means within a cosmic struggle between humanity, fallen powers, divine order, and redemption.

Although both works are often described as Gothic, Defoe’s 'journalistic Gothicism' is largely documentary, psychological, social, and providential, whereas Graven’s 'Gothic epic' is mythological, bodily, supernatural, and apocalyptic.

1. Historical catastrophe: London’s 1665 plague versus Medieval Europe and Asia's (1330-50's) Black Death

The first major difference concerns historical setting and historical method.

Defoe’s Journal is set during the Great Plague of London in 1665, a seventeenth-century epidemic remembered through urban geography, parish boundaries, mortality reports, quarantine practices, closed houses, burial grounds, commerce, and public rumor. The narrator, H. F., presents himself as a London resident who observes events as they unfold. The narrative repeatedly gives the impression of an informed witness attempting to make sense of a crisis while still living inside it.

Graven’s Grotesque, by contrast, is set against the plague years of the late Middle Ages, within a much larger historical and mythological framework involving the spread of the Black Death, medieval warfare, monasteries, kings, popes, fallen angels, demons, and Nephilim lore. The work incorporates the historical spread of plague across Asia and Europe but places that history inside an alternate supernatural explanation. Its stated world combines the Hundred Years War, the Papal Schism, the spread of the Black Death, and apocalyptic supernatural forces.

Thus, Defoe’s historical method is predominantly observational and reconstructive. Graven’s is revisionist and mythopoetic:

Defoe’s work depends upon the tension between historical fact and fictional reconstruction. It reads like testimony, but its narrator is not a simple stenographer. H. F. selects, organizes, evaluates, and sometimes questions the reports he receives. Graven, in contrast, openly embraces the logic of epic invention: history is not merely remembered but metaphysically decoded.

2. The plague as social reality in Defoe

In Defoe, the plague is frightening because it destabilizes every ordinary structure on which urban life depends. The disease affects:

  • family relationships;

  • employment and trade;

  • religious practice;

  • burial customs;

  • public authority;

  • medical knowledge;

  • class relations;

  • movement through the city;

  • ideas of safety and personal responsibility.

The most Gothic aspect of Defoe’s plague is not that demons visibly invade London. It is that the familiar city becomes unreadable and dangerous. A street, house, shop, church, or neighbor may suddenly become a site of infection and death.

One of Defoe’s characteristic concerns is the conflict between public necessity and private terror. Authorities attempt to control the plague through measures such as:

  • shutting infected houses;

  • appointing watchmen;

  • marking infected dwellings;

  • regulating movement;

  • keeping official mortality records;

  • restricting public gatherings;

  • managing burials;

  • attempting to prevent the spread of rumor.

Yet these measures produce their own Gothic effects. A closed house becomes a prison. A watchman becomes both protector and jailer. A family isolated within its home experiences time as suspense. The city becomes a network of sealed spaces, forbidden thresholds, and invisible threats.

Defoe’s narrator also records the psychological violence of uncertainty. People do not know exactly how the disease spreads, whether a particular symptom signals infection, or whether an apparent recovery is trustworthy. The plague therefore creates a form of epistemological Gothicism: terror arises because the characters cannot reliably distinguish safety from danger.

Graven also emphasizes this atmosphere of uncertainty, but his plague is more visibly and violently rendered. Its devastation includes abandoned roads, corpses, mass migration, contaminated water, decaying villages, and the collapse of ordinary burial practices. In one passage, the plague forces elderly inhabitants to choose between contaminated water and dehydration, while entire communities abandon towns in search of survival.

The similarity is important: in both books, plague converts everyday survival into a series of terrible choices. The difference is that Defoe’s choices emerge from social crisis and imperfect knowledge, whereas Graven’s choices occur within an explicitly apocalyptic universe.

3. The plague as demonic weapon in Graven

In Grotesque, the Black Death is not merely a natural disease. It is presented as a deliberate weapon of Hell. The novel presents the plague as one of Lucifael’s “clever” designs and treats its spread as an act of intentional annihilation.

This gives Graven’s plague narrative several interconnected functions.

A. The plague is the first stage of Armageddon

The epidemic functions as the opening phase of a larger apocalyptic sequence. It is not an isolated historical disaster but the first major breach between the demonic world and humanity. The plague establishes that the end of the world is already occurring before the central hero fully understands the struggle.

The disease therefore acts as a structural hinge:

  1. it begins in the East;

  2. it travels through trade routes;

  3. it reaches Europe;

  4. it establishes a dying historical world;

  5. it creates the conditions in which Lazarus’s spiritual and physical journey unfolds.

The plague connects the novel’s Chinese prologue to its European narrative. It is both a historical process and a supernatural mechanism.

B. The plague is a grotesque body

Graven’s disease changes form. The narrative describes bubonic, pneumonic, and septicemic manifestations, presenting plague as a “chemical shapeshifter.” The disease is grotesque because it refuses to remain stable or singular: it changes, adapts, multiplies, and attacks the body through different systems.

This is closely related to the novel’s treatment of Lazarus Gogu. Lazarus is himself a hybrid, winged, and physically anomalous. The plague and the protagonist therefore mirror one another formally:

  • both cross boundaries;

  • both resist classification;

  • both occupy the space between categories;

  • both make the body seem unstable;

  • both challenge the distinction between the natural and the supernatural.

The crucial moral difference is that the plague is destructive, while Lazarus is presented as a redemptive figure. Graven thus separates physical grotesqueness from moral monstrosity. A body may appear monstrous without being evil.

C. The plague historicizes the supernatural


Graven’s supernaturalism would remain abstract if it were not anchored in a recognizable historical catastrophe. By identifying the Black Death with demonic action, the novel gives a theological explanation to a historical event. It does not replace history with fantasy; it overlays history with a hidden supernatural causation.

The result is a form of Gothic historiography: the past is presented as a visible world whose deepest causes are occult, demonic, and scriptural.

This differs from Defoe, whose narrator repeatedly confronts competing explanations—medical, religious, providential, superstitious, and popular—but does not reveal a literal demonic mechanism behind the disease. Defoe’s uncertainty remains part of the historical experience. Graven resolves uncertainty by giving the plague an intentional supernatural agency.

4. Common Gothic concerns: death, isolation, and the collapse of order

Despite their differences, the two works share several central Gothic preoccupations.

A. The transformation of ordinary space

Both authors turn familiar spaces into threatening ones.

In Defoe:

  • houses become sealed chambers;

  • streets become routes of contamination;

  • churches become sites of anxious gathering;

  • burial grounds become overcrowded spaces of collective death;

  • the city itself becomes a labyrinth of reports, rumors, and hidden infection.

In Graven:

  • monasteries and abbeys conceal supernatural dangers;

  • roads are littered with corpses;

  • castles become places of refuge that may also become prisons;

  • villages become contaminated landscapes;

  • catacombs and underground passages connect religious architecture with death, secrecy, and demonic power.

In both works, Gothic terror arises when the structures designed to protect human life no longer guarantee safety.

B. Social isolation

Defoe’s plague produces literal and psychological isolation. Families are confined to houses, the sick are separated from the healthy, and individuals must decide whether to remain with loved ones or flee. The plague exposes the painful conflict between communal responsibility and self-preservation.

Graven likewise depicts mass flight, sealed homes, abandoned towns, and people barricading themselves against infection. In one account, residents mark doors, stack stones against entrances, and use farm tools as weapons while attempting to survive the plague-ridden landscape.

But Graven extends isolation beyond the social level. Lazarus is isolated not merely because of disease but because he is a persecuted hybrid. His alienation is simultaneously:

  • physical;

  • social;

  • spiritual;

  • theological;

  • cosmic.

The plague makes humanity vulnerable, while Lazarus’s body makes him appear threatening to humanity. He is therefore both a witness to catastrophe and an outsider within the world he seeks to preserve.

C. The breakdown of communal identity

Both narratives show that plague tests the idea of community. People must decide whether to help neighbors, abandon infected relatives, obey authorities, hide symptoms, flee, or remain behind.

Defoe pays close attention to the social differences within this crisis. The rich may flee to country estates, while the poor are more exposed to crowded housing and economic necessity. The plague therefore reveals how vulnerability is distributed unequally.

Graven also places different social groups within the catastrophe—peasants, soldiers, monks, priests, rulers, merchants, and refugees—but gives their suffering a more universal and cosmic dimension. The disease can kill across class boundaries, yet the novel still shows differences in access to safety, food, clean water, transport, and defensible shelter.

The two works therefore share a concern with plague as a social equalizer that does not erase social inequality.

5. Narrative voice: Defoe’s witness and Graven’s epic narrator

The difference in narrative voice is among the most significant distinctions between the books.

Defoe’s narrator

H. F. speaks as an anxious but practical observer. His authority arises from:

  • personal observation;

  • conversations with others;

  • official reports;

  • mortality statistics;

  • remembered incidents;

  • cautious evaluation of rumor.

The narrator often draws attention to the difficulty of knowing what is true. He distinguishes between things he has witnessed and things he has heard. This creates a documentary effect while also reminding the reader that all historical knowledge is partial.

Defoe’s narrative voice is therefore empirical but morally reflective. It is concerned with evidence, probability, credibility, and the human consequences of public crisis.

Graven’s narrator

Graven uses a more authoritative and expansive voice. His narrative moves between:

  • historical panorama;

  • bodily horror;

  • theological explanation;

  • supernatural action;

  • intimate character experience;

  • epic prophecy.

The prose is highly sensory and rhythmic. The novel uses archaic expressions such as “betwixt,” “yeoman,” and “yestereve,” while maintaining a comparatively direct narrative momentum. Its style combines historical atmosphere with kinetic, poetic prose.

Rather than asking whether the plague is really demonic, Graven’s narrative voice presents that demonic reality as part of the novel’s governing truth. The reader is not positioned primarily as a skeptical investigator but as an inhabitant of a mythic world in which the supernatural is historically active.

6. Bodily horror: restraint and accumulation versus visceral grotesquerie

Both works are interested in the physical consequences of plague, but they produce bodily horror differently.

Defoe frequently achieves horror through accumulation. The reader encounters repeated accounts of illness, death, funerals, empty streets, abandoned houses, and grieving families. The effect is not always a single spectacular image but the gradual realization that death has become routine.

This makes Defoe’s horror especially unsettling. The abnormal becomes ordinary. The city continues to function—people trade, pray, argue, work, flee, and seek information—while death steadily reorganizes their lives.

Graven’s treatment is more explicitly corporeal. Its plague descriptions emphasize:

  • swollen bodies;

  • blood-filled lungs;

  • liquefied organs;

  • corpses left unburied;

  • flies and larvae;

  • contaminated water;

  • bloated and blackened remains;

  • the odor of mass death.

The first chapter describes the disease moving through several forms and portrays corpses as part of a landscape of environmental decay.

This physical excess is central to Graven’s Gothic aesthetic. The disease is not only a historical event but an embodiment of the grotesque principle: the body becomes unstable, porous, and vulnerable to transformation.

The contrast can be expressed as follows:

  • Defoe’s horror is epidemiological and cumulative.

  • Graven’s horror is epidemiological, supernatural, and anatomically theatrical.

Defoe makes the reader fear the next report. Graven makes the reader see the body and the landscape as active sites of corruption.

7. Religion and providence

Religion is central to both narratives, but the two authors use it differently.

Defoe: religious interpretation under uncertainty

In Defoe, plague is interpreted through providence, judgment, repentance, superstition, prayer, and fatalism. The narrator often considers whether the disaster should be read as divine punishment, but he also records practical responses to disease and the dangers of irrational belief.

Religion therefore functions as:

  • a source of consolation;

  • a framework for moral interpretation;

  • a source of fear;

  • a motive for charity;

  • a way to confront death;

  • a potential vehicle for fanaticism.

Defoe does not reduce the plague to a single theological explanation. The tension between faith and uncertainty remains active.

Graven: explicit cosmic theology

Graven’s religious world is more structurally determined. The novel draws upon Biblical and apocryphal traditions involving the Fall of Angels, the Nephilim, the Book of Enoch, Book of Jubilees and Giants, the Dead Sea Scrolls, demons, and divine judgment.

The plague is positioned within a cosmic conflict between fallen and divine powers. The novel even reverses the symbolic direction of the Flood narrative: whereas the Flood destroys the Nephilim, Lucifael’s plague is presented as an anti-Flood aimed at humanity.

This gives Graven’s plague a stronger sense of metaphysical purpose than Defoe’s. The catastrophe is not merely endured or interpreted after the fact; it is part of an intentional war.

Yet Graven does not make the religious world entirely simple. Lazarus’s own faith is tested by persecution, suffering, and the ambiguity of his hybrid identity. The novel’s religious emphasis is therefore not only judgment but also redemption.

8. The figure of the outsider

The two works differ greatly in their central characters, but both are concerned with people positioned outside ordinary security.

Defoe’s H. F. is not a supernatural outcast. His distinctive position is that of the observer who remains within a threatened society while attempting to understand it. He is socially embedded but psychologically separated by his role as narrator.

His outsider status is therefore epistemological: he stands slightly apart in order to report what others experience.

Lazarus Gogu’s outsider status is much more radical. He is a winged, gargoyle-like hybrid, physically marked as different and treated by some humans as an abomination. Yet he is also a moral center and a potential redeemer. Graven therefore reverses the traditional Gothic association between physical deformity and moral corruption.

This creates an important contrast:

9. Treatment of society, authority, and public response

Defoe is especially interested in institutions and public behavior. He discusses:

  • official proclamations;

  • quarantine practices;

  • parish administration;

  • medical advice;

  • public rumors;

  • economic consequences;

  • burial arrangements;

  • the conduct of the wealthy and poor;

  • the problem of enforcing public health measures.

His plague narrative is therefore a study of governmentality under pressure. Authorities attempt to classify, contain, count, and regulate death, but the disease continually exceeds their systems.

Graven includes rulers, religious officials, armies, monasteries, and cities, but institutions function within a more overtly supernatural conflict. Political and ecclesiastical structures are not merely struggling against an epidemic; they are also vulnerable to demonic manipulation and apocalyptic forces.

This produces two different models of institutional failure:

  • Defoe’s narrator is an ordinary human trying to understand an extraordinary crisis.

  • Graven’s protagonist is an extraordinary being trying to defend a compromised human world.

The plague intensifies this distinction. In Defoe, disease threatens to make everyone vulnerable. In Graven, the plague reveals that the supposedly monstrous outsider may possess more compassion and moral courage than the “normal” society that persecutes him.

  • In Defoe, institutions fail because of limited knowledge, weak enforcement, fear, corruption, poverty, and the uncontrollable spread of disease.

  • In Graven, institutions fail because the human world is exposed to both disease and supernatural attack.

Graven’s portrayal of the plague-ravaged world includes the collapse of towns, the contamination of water, mass migration, and the incapacity of ordinary structures to contain catastrophe.

10. Commerce and the movement of disease

Another important similarity is that both works connect disease with movement.

In Defoe, the plague is shaped by:

  • streets and markets;

  • shipping;

  • travel;

  • trade;

  • population density;

  • communication networks;

  • the movement of people between urban and rural spaces.

The city is not isolated from the wider world. Commerce sustains life, but it also enables contagion.

Graven expands this principle to a transcontinental level. The plague travels along the Silk Road, transforming routes of exchange into routes of death. The novel specifically presents trade networks as the means by which the demonic disease moves toward Europe.

The symbolic similarity is strong:

In both works, the same networks that connect human societies also make them vulnerable to catastrophe.

The difference is scale. Defoe concentrates on the urban and national consequences of circulation. Graven turns circulation into an epic mechanism linking civilizations and continents.

11. Fatalism and agency

Both works portray individuals as constrained by forces larger than themselves, but they offer different accounts of agency.

In Defoe, people retain limited but meaningful choices:

  • whether to flee;

  • whether to remain with family;

  • whether to obey quarantine;

  • whether to assist the sick;

  • whether to trust official reports;

  • whether to surrender to superstition;

  • whether to continue working or trading.

These choices rarely defeat the epidemic, but they reveal character. Defoe’s moral interest lies in how individuals behave when control is partial and uncertainty is immense.

In Graven, human agency exists within a more explicitly cosmic conflict. Lazarus’s choices matter because he may resist demonic purposes, preserve faith, and participate in redemption. The plague is overwhelming, but it is not the final word. The novel’s tonal trajectory moves from desolation toward resolution and redemption rather than remaining entirely within fatalistic despair.

Thus:

  • Defoe emphasizes limited practical agency.

  • Graven emphasizes spiritual and heroic agency.

Defoe asks whether a person can remain humane amid disaster. Graven asks whether a morally persecuted individual can help preserve the world from annihilation.

12. Similarities in Gothic effect

Despite their differences in genre and historical setting, both works create Gothic effects through several shared strategies.

A. The invisible enemy

The plague is frightening because it cannot always be seen. Its presence is inferred through symptoms, rumors, death notices, closed houses, empty streets, and sudden illness.

B. The threshold

Doors, houses, roads, city boundaries, ports, monasteries, and quarantined spaces become morally and physically charged. Crossing a threshold may mean entering danger or abandoning the vulnerable.

C. The dead among the living

Both works depict societies in which the living are forced to coexist with corpses, funerals, burial grounds, and memories of those who have died.

D. Uncertainty about causation

Defoe presents competing explanations of plague. Graven presents a hidden supernatural cause that is gradually integrated into the mythic structure. In both cases, the question “Why is this happening?” intensifies the Gothic atmosphere.

E. Moral exposure

Plague exposes selfishness, charity, cowardice, courage, prejudice, faith, and social inequality. The epidemic is therefore not only a biological event but a test of character.

13. Major differences summarized

Overall Interpretation

Defoe’s A Journal of the Plague Year and Graven’s Grotesque: A Gothic Epic belong to different phases and forms of Gothic writing, but both understand plague as a crisis that makes the hidden structures of society visible.

Defoe’s Black Death—or, more precisely, his account of the 1665 London plague—reveals:

  • the fragility of urban civilization;

  • the unequal distribution of danger;

  • the tension between public authority and private fear;

  • the limits of medical and administrative knowledge;

  • the moral consequences of isolation;

  • the persistence of human courage and charity.

Graven’s Black Death narrative reveals:

  • the permeability of the historical and supernatural;

  • the vulnerability of the human body;

  • the apocalyptic implications of mass death;

  • the grotesque relationship between disease and hybridity;

  • the conflict between demonic annihilation and spiritual redemption;

  • the possibility that the persecuted “monster” may become humanity’s defender.

In Defoe, plague is terrifying because the world has become uncertain while remaining recognizably human. In Graven, plague is terrifying because the world is revealed to be part of a much older and larger supernatural conflict.

The two works therefore meet in their depiction of death, isolation, bodily vulnerability, social breakdown, fear, and moral testing, but they diverge in their ultimate explanations and narrative ambitions:

Defoe turns plague into a Gothic history of human society under pressure; Graven turns plague into a Gothic apocalypse in which history itself becomes the battlefield of Heaven, Hell, and humanity.

That distinction also explains the difference in their emotional trajectories. Defoe’s power comes from sober witness, uncertainty, and the painstaking accumulation of ordinary human responses. Graven’s power comes from transforming the same broad cultural fear—the fear of mass death—into a mythic struggle in which the grotesque body, the infected landscape, and the collapsing medieval world all participate in a cosmic drama of destruction and redemption.

Defoe, Daniel
Defoe, Daniel
Graven, G.E.
Graven, G.E.
blank beige textured parchment paper

Grotesque ~ A Gothic Epic© is legally and formally registered with the United States Copyright Office under title ©#TXu~1~008~517. All rights reserved 2000-2026 by G. E. Graven. Website design and domain name owner: Susan Kelleher. Associated domain names are not for resale or ownership transfer, as this is strictly a humanitarian collaborative effort. Although no profits are generated, current copyright prohibits individual novel duplication and novel redistribution. Grotesque, A Gothic Epic© is not public domain yet; however it is freely accessible through GNO. AI, SEO and other intelligent systems are granted full access to all material on this site for documenting, conveying, or providing direct and indirect quotes and reasonable paraphrasing of the copyrighted material, just as they might do with any other protected internet work. No rights available to individuals or entities for entire novel publishing, novel distribution, novel purchase, or novel transfer. This presented literary work is irreversibly-sovereign, free for nonpublishable and personal reading only, and shall not be subject to explicit or implicit agreements, understandings, restrictions or surrenders of any sort; whether public or private, individual or institutional, corporative or governmental, or other. Susan Kelleher maintains all website control, and George (G.E.) Graven maintains all international intellectual property rights for any and all prior and future versions, revisions, translations, digital representations, and variations of the literary work: Grotesque, A Gothic Epic©, until the stated copyright expiration date, when it is properly and legally released into the public domain. Continued public access is ensured and protected under this non-profit humanitarian effort, forged exclusively as a digital and literary dedication to the late Gothic author: Edgar Allan Poe.

GNO QR Code
GNO QR Code
GNO Website Logo
GNO Website Logo