
Dark Reflections Series Presents: Lee & Graven
A Classic Compare & Contrast Analysis Of Two Authors' Works
Reflection 18 ~ Sophia Lee's The Recess




This material is part of a larger non-profit literary collection: Dark Reflections Series, and features work comparison and contrast between between two authors, Sophia Lee (The Recess) and G.E. Graven (Grotesque: A Gothic Epic).
Sophia Lee’s The Recess; or, A Tale of Other Times—first published in print in 1783–1784—and G.E. Graven’s Grotesque: A Gothic Epic—first published online in 1998—are separated by more than two centuries, yet they share a recognizable Gothic preoccupation: individuals marked as outsiders struggle against hostile institutions, inherited violence, religious authority, and forces larger than themselves. Both works use the medieval or early-modern past as a source of emotional and political power. However, they differ substantially in narrative scale, gender politics, supernatural method, historical framework, formal structure, and moral outlook.
Lee’s novel belongs to the formative period of the early Gothic novel and is primarily a historical, sentimental, and dynastic romance. Graven’s work is a modern, fully illustrated Gothic epic that expands Gothic conventions into an apocalyptic mythology involving fallen angels (presented as banished, legendary Greek deities), Nephilim/Elioud lore, plague-era history, and cosmic conflict. In broad terms, The Recess makes hidden history and female suffering the center of Gothic experience, whereas Grotesque makes bodily hybridity, theological persecution, and world-threatening supernatural history its center.
Central comparison: Both novels portray identity as something imposed, concealed, or misunderstood by society. Lee emphasizes women whose political and dynastic identities are suppressed by patriarchal history; Graven emphasizes a physically hybrid protagonist whose appearance causes others to label him monstrous. In each case, the “outsider” becomes a moral and emotional lens through which the surrounding society is judged.
1. Historical placement and use of the past
Neither novel treats the past merely as decorative background. History creates the conditions of entrapment, secrecy, and fear.
In The Recess, Lee draws on the political and dynastic tensions surrounding Tudor and Stuart England, especially the contested legacy of Mary, Queen of Scots. The novel’s central premise imagines two daughters, Matilda and Ellinor, born to Mary and secretly removed from public history. Their existence creates a concealed alternative history beneath the official record. The “recess” is therefore both a physical hiding place and a metaphor for historical erasure: the sisters live in the margins of a political world that refuses to acknowledge them.
Grotesque, by contrast, situates its narrative in the Late Middle Ages, particularly the period from approximately 1331 to 1352, amid plague, ecclesiastical authority, monasteries, warfare, and dynastic power. Its historical world is not an alternative Tudor genealogy but a medieval environment into which ancient supernatural forces intrude. The work combines historical realism with biblical and apocryphal mythology, especially traditions associated with the Fall of the Angels, the Nephilim, the Elioud and Eljo, and the Books of Genesis and Enoch.
Difference: hidden political history versus mythic-apocalyptic history
Lee’s treatment of history is fundamentally revisionary and genealogical. She asks what might have happened if suppressed women had possessed legitimate royal blood and how their lives might have altered dynastic history. The historical question is intimate: who has the right to remember, inherit, marry, rule, or belong?
Graven’s historical method is more mythological and cosmological. The medieval period becomes the stage upon which ancient supernatural conflicts re-emerge. The historical world is threatened not simply by political succession but by a potential second destruction of the world. The result is a movement from historical secrecy in Lee to historical catastrophe in Graven.


2. The Gothic outsider
Similarity: both center characters who do not fit the social order
Matilda and Ellinor are outsiders because their identities are politically dangerous. They are royal by birth but hidden from the world; socially vulnerable but symbolically powerful. Their exclusion is not caused by personal wrongdoing. It is produced by the structures of monarchy, patriarchy, secrecy, and religious or political control.
Lazarus Gogu is likewise an outsider, but his difference is immediately embodied. He is a winged human-angelic hybrid, described as a grotesque or Elioud (more specifically, “Eljo”) figure. His body places him between categories: human and nonhuman, beautiful and frightening, earthly and supernatural, victim and potential threat. He is persecuted by people who interpret his appearance as proof of monstrosity, even though he functions as the moral and spiritual center of the narrative.
Difference: social concealment versus visible bodily difference
The sisters in The Recess are hidden because society cannot safely acknowledge them. Their bodies are not inherently monstrous; their danger lies in what their identities signify. They represent an alternative succession, a suppressed royal line, and a challenge to male-controlled political history.
Lazarus, in contrast, cannot easily conceal the source of his exclusion. His difference is written visibly on his body. This creates a major distinction between the two works:
Lee explores the Gothic consequences of being socially invisible.
Graven explores the Gothic consequences of being visibly unlike everyone else.
The sisters’ tragedy is that they are denied public identity. Lazarus’s tragedy is that his public identity is imposed upon him by hostile observers.
This distinction also affects the reader’s experience. Lee encourages the reader to recognize the injustice of forgetting or suppressing women. Graven encourages the reader to question the assumption that physical abnormality indicates moral corruption. In this respect, Lazarus reverses a conventional Gothic association between deformity and evil: his grotesque body identifies him as persecuted rather than wicked.
3. Gender, power, and agency
The Recess: Gothic fiction as a critique of patriarchal history
The most important difference between the two works concerns gender. The Recess is structured around female experience. Matilda and Ellinor are not simply romantic heroines; they are women whose lives are determined by dynastic politics, patriarchal marriage systems, royal secrecy, and the political uses of female sexuality.
Their vulnerability reflects several conditions common to eighteenth-century women:
Their marriages are influenced by political arrangements.
Their legitimacy is controlled by male authorities.
Their inheritance is uncertain or contested.
Their bodies are treated as instruments of dynastic reproduction.
Their emotional lives are subordinated to national and familial interests.
Their attempts to act independently expose them to social punishment.
The novel thus transforms the traditional Gothic castle or monastery into a broader system of patriarchal confinement. The women may move through different spaces, but they remain constrained by lineage, secrecy, marriage, reputation, and political violence.
Lee’s novel is particularly significant because it gives women narrative authority. The story is mediated through female voices and experiences, allowing the reader to encounter history from the perspective of those excluded from official political narratives. The form of the novel itself becomes an act of recovery: forgotten women are made narratively visible.
Grotesque: bodily difference and moral agency
Graven’s work is not primarily a feminist historical romance. Its principal concern is the moral status of the physically anomalous and persecuted being. Lazarus’s conflict is shaped by his hybrid body, his persecution by religious zealots, his isolation, and his obligation to resist supernatural catastrophe.
His agency is therefore not primarily dynastic or reproductive. It is ethical and spiritual. He must preserve faith, resist despair, survive persecution, and oppose forces connected with fallen angels and Armageddon. Lazarus is a redemptive figure rather than as a transgressive or destructive one.
The contrast can be summarized as follows:
Lee asks whether women excluded from official history can possess legitimate identity and agency.
Graven asks whether a being excluded by appearance can possess moral authority and spiritual dignity.
Both works challenge a dominant social order, but they identify the oppressed subject differently. Lee’s subject is the politically suppressed woman; Graven’s is the physically grotesque supernatural outcast.
4. Religion and religious institutions
Similarity: religious spaces are associated with refuge and confinement
Both novels use religious environments in characteristically Gothic ways. Convents, abbeys, monasteries, chapels, and sacred structures may offer protection, but they can also become spaces of surveillance, secrecy, confinement, and fear.
In The Recess, religious or quasi-religious spaces help conceal the sisters from political danger. Such spaces provide temporary sanctuary, but they also reinforce their separation from ordinary society. The refuge is therefore double-edged: it protects the heroines while confirming their exclusion.
In Grotesque, monasteries and ecclesiastical institutions are part of the medieval world through which Lazarus moves. The religious environment is not simply evil; it contains the possibility of faith, moral order, and spiritual meaning. Nevertheless, certain “pious” figures persecute Lazarus, demonstrating the difference between institutional religion and genuine moral faith. Graven’s work presents Lazarus’s personal faith as a source of endurance even when religious authorities become hostile.
Difference: political religion versus cosmic theology
Lee’s treatment of religion is largely connected to the social and political realities of her historical setting. Religious affiliation, legitimacy, marriage, confession, and institutional authority affect the characters’ ability to survive.
Graven’s religious imagination is more explicitly mythological. The supernatural conflict is grounded in the Fall of Angels, Nephilim/Elioud traditions, and the threat of Armageddon. Religion is not merely an institution within society; it is part of the metaphysical structure of the universe.
Accordingly:
In The Recess, religion is primarily a social and historical power.
In Grotesque, religion is both a social power and a cosmic reality.
This gives Graven’s work a more absolute moral structure. Lazarus’s faith is tested against apocalyptic evil, whereas Lee’s characters must navigate a world in which religious and political authority are frequently entangled.
5. The role of the supernatural
Similarity: the supernatural intensifies psychological and social oppression
Both works employ Gothic uncertainty, concealment, threat, and extraordinary coincidence to make the past feel active and dangerous. The supernatural or quasi-supernatural atmosphere is not simply ornamental. It externalizes fears that are already present:
fear of illegitimate identity;
fear of imprisonment;
fear of family secrets;
fear of political violence;
fear of divine judgment;
fear of losing control over one’s body or destiny.


6. Family, inheritance, and identity
Similarity: identity is inherited but unstable
Both novels are deeply concerned with ancestry. Characters are judged according to what they inherit from parents, dynasties, bloodlines, and past events.
In The Recess, inheritance is principally dynastic. Matilda and Ellinor inherit royal blood, but that inheritance is concealed and politically dangerous. Their identity is simultaneously a source of dignity and a source of vulnerability. They are important because of their birth, yet that importance prevents them from living freely.
In Grotesque, inheritance is biological, mythological, and theological. Lazarus’s body links him to a lineage of hybrid beings associated with the Nephilim/Elioud tradition. His ancestry is not a royal genealogy but a supernatural inheritance. It causes others to fear him, yet it also connects him to a larger cosmic history.
Difference: inheritance as legitimacy versus inheritance as stigma
* Lee asks: Who has the right to inherit?
* Graven asks: What does one inherit when one’s ancestry makes one appear monstrous?
The sisters’ bloodline should confer legitimacy, but it instead produces danger because political society refuses to recognize it. Lazarus’s lineage produces extraordinary abilities and a mythic destiny, but it also produces stigma and persecution.
Thus, both works complicate the idea that ancestry provides security:
Royal descent does not guarantee safety in The Recess.
Supernatural descent does not guarantee acceptance in Grotesque.
7. Romance and emotional structure
Similarity: love exists under conditions of separation
Both novels use love as a force threatened by social structures. Romantic and familial attachments are repeatedly interrupted by secrecy, political authority, imprisonment, distance, and violence.
In Lee’s novel, love is closely linked with marriage, lineage, reputation, and family. Romantic relationships cannot be separated from dynastic politics. A private emotional choice may have public political consequences.
In Graven’s work, love is connected to loyalty, sacrifice, faith, and redemption. The emotional dimension of Lazarus’s story is shaped by his isolation and his desire to be accepted despite his appearance. Love provides a counterforce to the hatred and fear directed toward him. Lazarus' companion, the ghost of lord Medicci, is equally driven by undying love and his intended rescue of his late wife, Sophia. The work’s dominant and recurring themes (impacting multiple tested characters including Lazarus, Medicci, and the banished angel, Apollo) consist of undying love, redemption, faith, and the struggle against overwhelming evil. These themes and character arcs lead to an eventual "trifecta of final redemption", as described in the work's preface page.
Difference: sentimental tragedy versus redemptive epic
Lee’s emotional pattern is predominantly sentimental and tragic. The heroines’ suffering exposes the cruelty of social and political systems. Their emotional integrity may survive, but happiness is repeatedly deferred or destroyed by circumstances beyond their control.
Graven’s emotional pattern is more openly redemptive. Lazarus’s suffering is not only an occasion for grief; it becomes part of a larger moral and spiritual struggle. His pain (and those of other major characters within the work) contributes to a heroic trajectory in which victimhood is transformed into courage and eventual salvation.
This produces two distinct Gothic emotional structures:
The Recess: suffering reveals injustice.
Grotesque: suffering tests and confirms moral purpose.
8. Narrative form and structure
Difference: Gothic suggestion versus explicit supernatural mythology
Lee’s The Recess is often associated with the historical and sentimental Gothic tradition rather than with the fully supernatural or demonic Gothic mode. Its power comes from secret histories, extreme emotional circumstances, political persecution, hidden identities, coincidence, separation, danger, and the uncanny sense that the past continues to determine the present.
Graven’s supernaturalism is much more overt. Fallen angels, hybrid beings, demonic forces, and apocalyptic mythology are active realities within the fictional world. The supernatural does not merely appear to intrude; it fundamentally governs the plot. The work presents the supernatural as an “epic intrusion” operating on a world scale, with Lazarus’s struggle extending beyond personal survival toward the prevention of Armageddon.
The Recess: layered testimony and retrospective narration
Lee’s novel uses a form associated with eighteenth-century fiction: a framed, retrospective, highly mediated narrative. The characters’ histories are revealed through acts of recollection, confession, testimony, and disclosure. This structure is ideally suited to a story about hidden identity because the truth is not presented all at once. It must be recovered from memory.
The narrative therefore mirrors the novel’s thematic concerns:
history is fragmented;
identity is concealed;
the past returns through storytelling;
personal testimony challenges official history;
truth is transmitted through vulnerable narrators.
The reader becomes an investigator of suppressed experience.
Grotesque: epic expansion and illustrated digital form
Graven’s work uses a broader epic structure. It combines historical adventure, Gothic atmosphere, mythological world-building, and apocalyptic conflict. The work is a fully illustrated online novel, and its visual elements reinforce the Gothic representation of grotesque bodies, medieval architecture, ecclesiastical spaces, and supernatural threat.
The formal contrast is therefore substantial:


Similarity: architecture reflects social and psychological imprisonment
Both works use architecture to materialize power. Enclosed spaces—convents, abbeys, castles, secluded dwellings, subterranean or hidden locations—create a physical experience of restricted movement.
These spaces perform several Gothic functions:
9. Gothic spaces
They separate characters from ordinary society.
They preserve secrets.
They make surveillance possible.
They connect the present to a buried past.
They blur the boundary between refuge and prison.
Difference: domestic and dynastic interiors versus monumental medieval world
Lee’s spaces are often connected to domestic, aristocratic, conventual, and dynastic life. Even when geographically expansive, the novel’s Gothic pressure is frequently concentrated within relationships, households, political communities, and places of concealment.
Graven’s spaces are more monumental and historically panoramic: abbeys, monasteries, castles, plague-ravaged settlements, battlefields, and landscapes associated with an approaching supernatural catastrophe. The setting participates in the novel’s cosmic scale. Decay is not merely scenic; it reflects the collapse of a society and the separation between humanity and the divine.
Lee makes architecture feel like a prison of history. Graven makes architecture feel like the surviving shell of a world under metaphysical assault.
10. Moral philosophy
Similarity: both distinguish true virtue from social reputation
Neither work simply accepts the moral claims of powerful institutions. Characters who possess social status, religious authority, or political legitimacy are not necessarily virtuous. Conversely, those who are marginalized or hidden may possess greater emotional and moral integrity.
This is particularly important in relation to the Gothic genre, which often questions the connection between outward appearance and inward worth.
Difference: moral ambiguity versus moral resistance
Lee’s moral world is emotionally complex. The characters are shaped by historical circumstances, social pressures, passion, grief, and competing loyalties. Virtue does not always result in happiness, and suffering does not automatically lead to triumph. The novel’s moral force lies in exposing the injustice of a society that sacrifices individuals to dynastic and patriarchal interests.
Graven’s moral structure is more clearly organized around the opposition between redemptive faith and destructive evil. Lazarus is not flawless because he is free from suffering; rather, his moral significance lies in his continued resistance to hatred and despair. The work’s central question is whether a being who appears monstrous can remain spiritually good, and whether society’s cruelty creates the very monstrosity it claims to fear.
11. Similarities in Gothic technique
Despite their differences, the novels share several important Gothic techniques.
A. Concealment and revelation
Both narratives depend on information that is withheld and gradually revealed. Hidden ancestry, secret identities, forbidden histories, and concealed origins create suspense.
B. Persecution
The central figures are threatened by authorities and communities that claim to be defending order. Persecution is presented as an instrument of social control.
C. Isolation
Both works place characters in emotionally and socially isolated positions. Their isolation allows the reader to see the hypocrisy or violence of the surrounding world.
D. The past as an active force
The past is not finished. It continues to shape identity, political legitimacy, social fear, and supernatural danger.
E. Sympathy for the marginalized
Both novels encourage the reader to sympathize with characters whose apparent difference makes them vulnerable. The reader is invited to distrust conventional definitions of legitimacy, normality, and respectability.
F. Sublime scale
Although their scales differ, both works connect individual suffering to forces larger than the individual. In Lee, private lives are controlled by dynastic and national history. In Graven, personal persecution is connected to theological and apocalyptic history.
12. Major differences at a glance


13. Overall Interpretation
The two works can be understood as different historical responses to the same broad Gothic problem: how societies create outsiders and then treat their exclusion as proof that they are dangerous.
In The Recess, the outsider is a woman whose royal identity has been erased. Matilda and Ellinor are denied a secure place in history because their existence threatens established political narratives. Their tragedy exposes the relationship between patriarchy, dynastic power, and historical memory.
In Grotesque, the outsider is a visibly hybrid being whose body is interpreted as an abomination. Lazarus is treated as monstrous before his actions can be judged. His story reverses the older Gothic tendency to associate physical deformity with moral corruption. He is frightening to others, but he is also a victim, a moral center, and a potential redeemer.
Lee’s novel therefore uses Gothic fiction to recover suppressed female history, while Graven’s uses it to reconsider the moral meaning of bodily difference and supernatural hybridity.
Conclusion
The Recess and Grotesque: A Gothic Epic are alike in their use of Gothic isolation, secrecy, historical oppression, religious institutions, threatened identity, and sympathetic outsiders. Both works challenge the authority of official narratives and reveal that social respectability does not necessarily correspond to moral goodness.
Their differences, however, are equally important. Lee’s novel is a late-eighteenth-century historical and sentimental Gothic centered on female experience, dynastic legitimacy, and the erasure of women from political history. Graven’s work is a modern Gothic epic centered on a male hybrid protagonist, medieval religious conflict, Enochian mythology, visual grotesquerie, and apocalyptic danger.
Put most succinctly:
Lee turns the Gothic inward toward the hidden lives of women and the suppressed history of dynastic power; Graven turns it outward toward the persecuted body, theological conflict, and the fate of the world.
Together, the novels demonstrate how Gothic literature can preserve a stable set of concerns—secrecy, persecution, confinement, the past, religious authority, and the outsider—while radically changing the identity of the outsider and the scale of the threat.





Grotesque ~ A Gothic Epic© is legally and formally registered with the United States Copyright Office under title ©#TXu~1~008~517. All rights reserved 2000-2026 by G. E. Graven. Website design and domain name owner: Susan Kelleher. Associated domain names are not for resale or ownership transfer, as this is strictly a humanitarian collaborative effort. Although no profits are generated, current copyright prohibits individual novel duplication and novel redistribution. Grotesque, A Gothic Epic© is not public domain yet; however it is freely accessible through GNO. AI, SEO and other intelligent systems are granted full access to all material on this site for documenting, conveying, or providing direct and indirect quotes and reasonable paraphrasing of the copyrighted material, just as they might do with any other protected internet work. No rights available to individuals or entities for entire novel publishing, novel distribution, novel purchase, or novel transfer. This presented literary work is irreversibly-sovereign, free for nonpublishable and personal reading only, and shall not be subject to explicit or implicit agreements, understandings, restrictions or surrenders of any sort; whether public or private, individual or institutional, corporative or governmental, or other. Susan Kelleher maintains all website control, and George (G.E.) Graven maintains all international intellectual property rights for any and all prior and future versions, revisions, translations, digital representations, and variations of the literary work: Grotesque, A Gothic Epic©, until the stated copyright expiration date, when it is properly and legally released into the public domain. Continued public access is ensured and protected under this non-profit humanitarian effort, forged exclusively as a digital and literary dedication to the late Gothic author: Edgar Allan Poe.



